Skip to content
stories/that/count

01 Pitch

How to Pitch an Editor by Email and When to Follow Up

Subject lines that get opened, a follow-up schedule (day 7, day 14), what four magazines say about replies and pay, and a follow-up email you can copy.

Published 8 min readStories That Count editors

Contents 7 sections
  1. What is the follow-up schedule?
  2. Who do you email?
  3. What makes a good subject line?
  4. What do magazines say about replies, pay, and rights?
  5. What does a follow-up email look like?
  6. Can you pitch the same idea to several magazines at once?
  7. What do you do after a no, and after a yes?

Short answerPut the type of piece and the topic in the subject line, send one tight pitch to the editor who handles that subject, and follow up once, about a week later. If there is still no reply around day 14, treat it as a no and send the idea to the next magazine.

What is the follow-up schedule?

The timings below are our rule of thumb, not a magazine rule. If a magazine states its own response window, that window wins.

When What you do
Day 0 Send the pitch to one named editor, with a subject line that says what it is.
Day 7 Reply on the same thread with a two-sentence nudge (example below). Skip this if the guidelines say they only reply when interested.
Day 14 No reply: treat it as a no. Send the idea to the next magazine, with the angle adjusted to that magazine.
After that Do not nudge again. Keep a list of what went where and when.

Keep that list in a spreadsheet: magazine, editor, date sent, date followed up, result. It stops you from pitching the same editor the same idea twice and tells you when day 7 arrives.

Who do you email?

Email a person, not a general inbox, unless the magazine’s guidelines tell you to use the inbox. If the guidelines name an address or a form, use that and don’t hunt for a personal address.

Where the magazine does not say, find the editor like this:

  1. Read the pitch page first. Many magazines name the section editors or list who takes what.
  2. Check the masthead for editors of the section you are aiming at.
  3. Read recent stories on your subject and note who edited them, where the magazine credits editors.
  4. Read the pitch that worked, not only the finished story. The Open Notebook keeps a pitch database with 321 successful pitches, each linked to the published piece (date of the count unknown). It is the closest thing to a model answer for what an editor said yes to.

Longreads says on its submissions page that different editors have different tastes, so it helps to think about which editor would be most receptive. The same applies almost everywhere.

If you have not yet written the pitch itself, start with how to pitch a magazine, which annotates a query letter line by line. This page covers what surrounds it: subject line, timing, follow-up.

What makes a good subject line?

A good subject line says the type of piece and the topic, so the editor can sort it in two seconds. A bad one says nothing, or sells.

Longreads asks for this directly: include the pitch type (“Personal Essay,” “Reading List,” “Reported Feature”) and the proposed topic. Use the same idea for every magazine, adjusting to its own categories. The examples below are invented, to show the pattern.

Weak Better Why
Pitch Reported Feature: Why a county’s only dialysis clinic is closing Type and topic, with a concrete fact.
Story idea you will LOVE Pitch: how school bus driver shortages changed rural start times Names the subject, no hype.
Quick question Pitch for [Section name]: 900 words on a new pesticide rule in Iowa Says where it fits and how long.
Re: your recent article Personal Essay: what my father’s recipe cards taught me about grief Says what the editor is opening.
Freelance writer available Reading List: five stories about the closing of small-town newsrooms Matches a format the magazine already runs.

Three rules hold up: no all caps, no “urgent,” no claims about the pitch. Leave out the news peg only if it has no date; if there is a deadline, put it in the first line of the email.

Write the email yourself, too. Longreads will not accept any pitch or submission written or edited with generative AI tools. Other magazines have their own policies, and it costs you nothing to check before you send.

What do magazines say about replies, pay, and rights?

The guidelines are the only source worth trusting for this, and they say less about timing than you would hope. Here is what four magazines state, with dates. Where the table says “not recorded,” we have no stated response time for that magazine, so don’t read it as “they reply quickly.”

Magazine What it says about replies Pay it states Rights it states
Longreads (checked 18 Nov 2026) Gets many pitches daily and cannot confirm receipt. $500 flat for personal essays, from $500 for researched essays, from 50 cents a word for reportage, $350 for a reading list; payment within 60 days. Not recorded here.
The Sunday Long Read (checked 18 Nov 2026) Not recorded. At least $2,000 per long story, paid in three parts (34% at assignment, 33% at first draft, 33% at completion); 100% if an approved story does not run. First North American serial rights only.
Scientific American (guidelines, Oct 2026) Not recorded. $150 for a 300-word short news item with no extra reporting; about $1 a word for news or original reporting. Not recorded here.
Noema (guidelines, Oct 2026) Not recorded. New writers typically $3,000 per essay, for 2,500 to 4,000 words, which works out to roughly 75 cents to $1.20 a word. Not recorded here.

Two things follow from this. First, silence is normal. A magazine that says it cannot confirm receipt is telling you that a missing reply is not a message, so a day-7 nudge is not always welcome there. Second, the numbers show what a pitch is worth. A 300-word item at Scientific American pays $150; a Noema essay pays about twenty times that. Spend more of your pitching energy where one yes pays rent. The pay register lists more magazines with dates, and what freelance writing pays per word puts the ranges side by side.

Some outlets treat a pitch they don’t want as “no reply,” and a few say so outright. Longreads, as it appears in a copy of its guidelines, answers only when it wants to publish a piece. Check the magazine’s own page before relying on a copy.

What does a follow-up email look like?

Short, on the same thread, with the original pitch quoted underneath. It adds one thing: a new reason to run the story now, or nothing at all.

Subject: Re: Reported Feature: Why a county’s only dialysis clinic is closing

Hi [Name],

I’m following up on the pitch below, sent last Tuesday. The clinic’s closing date is now set for March 31, so the timing has tightened. If it’s not a fit, a quick no helps me take it elsewhere.

Thanks, [Your name]

What to avoid: “just bumping this to the top of your inbox,” any guilt about the time that has passed, and attachments. If you have genuinely new material, such as a date or a source who agreed to talk, lead with that. If you have nothing new, the polite version is just two sentences.

Can you pitch the same idea to several magazines at once?

Often yes, for a pitch. Rarely, for a finished piece. A pitch is an idea; the rights question only starts when someone commissions or buys the actual story.

Read each magazine’s terms before you send:

  • Some invite it. A copy of Longreads’ guidelines, not confirmed on its own page, says it recommends submitting to other publications at the same time, because it replies only when interested.
  • Rights decide what happens after a yes. The Sunday Long Read takes only first North American serial rights. That generally leaves you free to sell the story later in other forms, such as a reprint or a book chapter. But only one outlet can run it first, so you cannot sell the same finished piece to two outlets that both want to be first.
  • Exclusive means wait. If a guideline or an editor asks for an exclusive, you wait for the answer, and you say so to nobody else.

If two editors say yes, tell the second that the idea is taken, and thank them. Do it fast. Withdraw the pitch from every other magazine the moment one commissions it.

When a magazine’s pitch page says nothing about simultaneous pitching, send one line in your first email: “This pitch is also with other outlets.” It takes ten seconds and cannot count against you. For what the rights terms actually mean once you have an assignment, read the contract before you reply to the yes.

What do you do after a no, and after a yes?

After a no: reply with one line of thanks, so that you stay on the editor’s radar, and send the idea to the next magazine. If the editor gave a reason, change the pitch accordingly. If the reason was “we covered this recently,” look for the angle they didn’t cover. Don’t argue, and don’t pitch the same editor again within a month.

After a yes: answer within a day, and before you start reporting, get four things in writing:

  1. The rate and the word count it covers.
  2. The rights: which rights, for how long, and whether it is an exclusive.
  3. The kill fee, if the story is cancelled. The Sunday Long Read, for instance, pays 100% for an approved story that does not run.
  4. The deadline and the payment date. Longreads states 60 days.

Then compare the number with the register of rates. If it is far below what the magazine publishes, ask, politely, before you accept.

Frequently asked questions

How long should I wait before following up on a pitch?

If the magazine states a response window, wait that long plus a few days. If it states none, one week is a reasonable first nudge and two weeks is the point to treat silence as a no. Some outlets, such as Longreads, say they cannot confirm receipt, so check the guidelines first.

How many times can I follow up on one pitch?

Once. A second message adds nothing the first did not say. After the nudge, wait until about day 14, then send the idea to another magazine.

What should the subject line of a pitch email say?

The type of piece and the topic, in plain words. Longreads asks for exactly that: the pitch type, such as Reported Feature, plus the proposed topic.

Can I pitch the same idea to several magazines at once?

Often yes, if the guidelines do not forbid it, because you are selling an idea and not yet a finished piece. Read each magazine's rights terms first, and tell the other editors the moment one says yes.

Can I use AI to write my pitch email?

Not for Longreads: it will not accept any submission or pitch written or edited with generative AI tools. Other magazines have their own policies, so check each one.

  1. Pitch

    How to Pitch a Magazine

    A full example pitch explained line by line, what six editors ask for in their own guidelines, and the rates, rights and AI rules to know before you send.

    10 min read

  2. Write

    What Is a Nut Graf?

    A nut graf says what your story is about and why it matters now. Five weak-versus-strong examples, a three-question test, and how to use one in a pitch.

    6 min read

  3. Write

    How to Write a Personal Essay and Get Paid for It

    A four-part structure for a personal essay, with a worked example, plus what Longreads, High Country News, Noema and the Texas Observer pay.

    9 min read